When Land Becomes a Financial Instrument: Carbon, Credits, and the £14m Lease

Land Campiagner Andy Whiteman has unveiled the true extent of the land market madness in Scotland in his latest blog - essential reading here: https://andywightman.scot/2025/09/the-12-million-farm-sale-and-the-14-million-lease



I responded to Andy thus:

Andy, hope you're well. Another incisive piece that perfectly captures the surreal financialisation of Scotland's land.

Your analysis of the £12m sale and £14m leaseback is the clearest case study yet of a phenomenon I've witnessed firsthand while trying to acquire land for genuine conservation: the creation of a natural capital speculative bubble.

My experience with the Woodland Carbon Code (WCC) and Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG) markets confirms that this isn't just land trading; it's a fundamental re-engineering of land as a financial instrument. Upland estates are no longer valued for their agricultural, tax dodging or 'sporting' potential, but as factories for producing environmental commodities.

The Financial Engine of the Bubble

As you've identified, the driver is the ability to calculate the Net Present Value (NPV) of future ecosystem service revenue. With WCC credits soaring from £5-8/tonne to £20-30+/tonne, a single large estate can now model millions in future carbon income. When you layer on the potential for BNG credits (selling at £30,000-£40,000 per hectare for high-value habitats), Natural Flood Management grants, and other public subsidies, you create a "perfect storm" of speculative valuation that completely detaches price from productive capacity.

The New Buyer Profile: Global Capital, Not Local Stewards

The market is now dominated by actors with entirely different motives and capital reserves:

Natural Capital Funds: Specialised investment vehicles treating land as a portfolio asset class.

Corporates & Banks: Engaging in "insetting" by directly owning land to offset their emissions, effectively vertically integrating their supply chain for ESG compliance.

High-Net-Worth Individuals: Chasing a "green legacy" and tax-efficient wealth preservation, spurred by instability in other asset classes.

These entities are not just outbidding local communities and farmers; they are operating in a different economic universe altogether.

Political Complicity and the Inevitable Populist Backlash

You are absolutely right to point the finger at political facilitation. Both the SNP and Labour have hitched their green credentials to this model of private finance, believing it's the only way to meet climate targets without public investment. In doing so, they are actively enabling a system that holds the public to ransom—we must either pay inflated prices for ecosystem services or fail to meet our legal environmental commitments.

This is not a stable system. The bubble will pop. It will likely burst when a combination of factors collide: a future government U-turn, a scandal over the validity of credits, or—as you rightly hint—a populist backlash from a Trump/Farage-style movement that successfully frames this as a "green tax on ordinary people" that enriches a new elite of eco-financiers.

The Unspoken Solution: A System We're Powerless to Implement

We know the answer. A direct Land Value Tax (LVT) would capture this unearned rental value for the public good, deflating the speculative bubble and forcing land to be used productively. A robust carbon tax at the source would be a more efficient way to drive down emissions than this convoluted, rentier-friendly offset market.

But these solutions remain politically impossible precisely because the economic forces you've exposed have a death grip on public policy. The Leadhills-Gresham deal isn't an anomaly; it's the logical endpoint of a system designed to create private wealth from public ecological crises.

Your work in documenting this is more vital than ever.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Beaver, Rewilding & Land Value Tax have the answer to the UK's Flooding Problem.

Image
Interesting the solution to the problems of flooding is the same for many of the problems facing Britain in the economic, housing and environmental crisis: Tax land values. This is because marginal farmland which is only farmed because of enormous taxpayer subsidies, and produces little food, will come out of production and can revert to flood plain and naturally water absorbing wild land - saving us from the flooding My press release on these issues of flooding: Beaver & Rewilding have the answer to the UK's Flooding Problem. _____________________________________________ Peter Smith, Wildwood Trust Chief Executive said: “It took the death of school children in a catastrophic flood event to shock the Dutch authorities to really tackle flooding on the Rhine; one of their answers was to stop farming on flood plain and to create a giant natural wetland, managed by wild horses, to prevent this tragedy from happening again.” _______________________________________________ ...
Read more

Zen and the Art of Land Value Tax

Image
  Or why the green movement has trouble accepting the one policy that will guarantee their objectives.   Land Value Tax (LVT) in its full theory is very complicated and to understand it properly requires a lot of thought and to mechanistically work out how it is fundamental to the protection of nature & natural assets. I myself have been attacked at conferences by well-meaning greens who’s hostility and almost zeal at condemning LVT leaves me depressed and confused as to their thinking. Why such people should have such anger, denial and almost  willful  need not to educate themselves of the economics of environmental destruction needs further investigation.  My best answer for this came from the similarities to the title theme of Robert M. Pirsig's bestselling book ‘Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance’ exploring the ‘Metaphysics of Quality’. Even though LVT is official Green Party Policy, explaining LVT to the leaders of the gree...
Read more

How do we stop the Insect Apocalypse?

Image
There have been a number of articles this week on the insect apocalypse, with some studies showing an 80% drop in insect numbers since the late 90s. These come from the car windshield splatter effect. We now see so few bugs splattered across our windscreen when many of us over 40 in childhood saw  our car windscreen splattered with insects, and every stop our parents had to wipe hundreds of squashed bugs from our windscreens during the summer. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/feb/12/car-splatometer-tests-reveal-huge-decline-number-insects More detailed studies in Germany have identified a 75% decline in flying insect numbers over a 26 year period. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0185809 As regular readers of this blog will know, I am far more interested in practical solutions to ecological problems than in the endless, often misleading debates presented in mainstream media. One of my pet hates is the way these “futile dilemm...
Read more